Five Ways CVC Secondaries are Different​

A corporate venture stake is often more complex to sell than a VC fund’s stake in the same company. The equity may be identical, but the CVC stake may suffer from thinner information, tighter transfer rules, a parent company’s reputational concerns, commercial ties to the startup, and internal constituents that want different things from the sale.

Generalist secondary advisors tend to discover these problems mid-process, when they are most expensive.

We plan for them from the first conversation.

1. Lack of information

  • The problem. Startups may share less data with corporate investors than with financial ones. A corporate parent may be a future competitor customer or acquirer, so founders may limit what it sees. And many CVCs hold minority stakes with weak information rights, and have internal firewalls to keep the venture team from sharing data with the parent’s business units.
  • Why it matters. Thin information results in fewer bidders, wider bid-ask spreads and deeper discounts.
  • How we handle it. We build a buyer-ready diligence package from what you are permitted to share, work with the company to fill the gaps, and target buyers who know how to underwrite with limited data, and who are already familiar with the sector, and possibly, the holding.

2. Transfer restrictions

  • The problem. Rights of first refusal, co-sale rights, company consent requirements and lists of prohibited buyers are common. And CVCs may have additional restrictions where portfolio companies are wary of a corporate’s stake ending up with a competitor.
  • Why it matters. The restrictions can discourage buyers from spending time and resources on diligence if they believe a ROFR will be exercised, or a transfer will be blocked.
  • How we handle it. We provide potential buyers with clarity on both the legal restrictions on transfer, and the real-world likelihood that they will block sale. We shape the buyer list so the company can say yes. And on a portfolio sale, we counsel buyers to allocate bids among the portfolio to decrease the likelihood that ROFRs are exercised.

3. Reputational concerns

  • The problem. When a corporate sells, people read it as a signal. The CVC or the parent may be concerned that the market views a secondary sale as an indication of distress. The startup may worry that it hurts the next fundraise. Other founders may wonder whether the CVC is still a reliable venture partner.
  • Why it matters. A leaky process, poor messaging, or the wrong buyer can impact the parent company’s reputation, or damage relationships the CVC depends on for future deal flow.
  • How we handle it. We run controlled, confidential outreach, agree on messaging with you and the company in advance, and help you choose buyers that will play well – internally and externally.

4. Strategic entanglements

  • The problem. A CVC stake is often tied to a commercial relationship: a supply, licensing, distribution or development agreement, plus Board seats, information rights or exclusivity terms. Some of these survive a sale, some end with it, and some depend on the equity staying put.
  • Why it matters. Buyers discount positions with strings they don't understand. Selling without a plan for the commercial relationship can damage a partnership the business unit still values.
  • How we handle it. We work out with you which ties stay and which go, then present the position to buyers with those terms already clear.

5. Mismatched stakeholder expectations

  • The problem. A CVC sale has many internal owners. The venture team wants a clean exit. The business unit may want to keep the relationship. Finance cares about price against carrying value and the hit to earnings. Legal cares about restrictions and disclosure. Leadership wants it done quickly and quietly. Each group works on its own timeline.
  • Why it matters. Deals stall when stakeholders learn what the market will pay only after bids arrive. A sale below the mark can also trigger a writedown the CFO didn't plan for.
  • How we handle it. We give you a realistic read on price and timing before launch, help you align objectives and decision rights internally, and keep every stakeholder informed through close.

The result

When these issues are handled up front, a CVC stake can sell on strong terms. In a recent engagement, we sold a European energy company’s CVC position for more than 3x NAV in a 90-day process, despite limited cooperation from the portfolio company. Case Study

Considering a sale? We can give you a confidential read on which holdings will sell, what buyers will pay, and what could get in the way.